Search:

I was pretty surprised too when the Android AoS app told me my Arachnarok was now a wood elf!

15879

Dat's awsum!

Anyway, the ASF rule clearly states that the initiative just needs to be EQUAL or higher to grant re-rolls on misses. It also clearly states that if both models have ASF, neither gets a re-roll.
...

To simplify, I believe he's looking for the question to this:

Model A with I9, ASF, Hand weapon
vs.
Model B with I2, ASF, Great Weapon

Does Model A get a reroll?

I don't know why anyone would even feel the need to so heatedly debate the aestethics of stylized game pieces. As far as I know, they can't force you to buy or use them. So use the democratic power...