Which primarch is the best fighter

[Montpup]

This is always up for debate but now we are beginning to see them in the game it will be interesting to see how they handle it

The few facts we have of combat between them follows

Horus kills the angel
Corax beats up logar
Corax avoids the night hunter, doesn't think he can beat him
The lion almost kills cruze (but cruze gets better, second fight cruze legs it)
Fulgrim kills manus
Russ cripples Magnus and kills the other 2
The lion beats Russ who then keeps fighting and beats up the lion (problerly showing why he does the job that he does)
Cruze beats up dorn
Lord of the smurfs kills one of the twins (maybe but as alpha legion win everything most likely not)
All of them think logar is a loser
Cruze eats humans, but doesn't really like the taste
Logar beats the Fulgrim daemon to pulp

[Kyban]

Horus kills the angel

Horus is daemon powered by that point though.

[eldargal]

Whichever one needs to be to further the plot.

[Deadlift]

I think it's generally accepted that The Blood Angels primarch is the most martial of the primarchs, His death at Horus's hands is because he is at that point gifted by chaos.

References are made to this is some of the HH books.

[Learn2Eel]

The way I've seen it;

Most Powerful - Sanguinius
Best Psyker - Magnus

They all have their own traits though. You could Alpharius/Omegon can simply avoid the others and never be truly killed.

[eldargal]

Aaron Dembski-Bowden said something along the lines that they are all at a similar level, they just have good and bad days. And then get posessed by daemons which makes things a bit nore confusing.

Edit: I can spell Dembski-Bowden from memory but misspell Aaron, nice.

[Mr Mystery]

The Lion very nearly slots Nighthaunter, and has also dropped Russ.

No contest.

On rules? I don't fancy getting into a punch with Horus or Mortarion....

[Deadlift]

Yeah but that was a cheap shot on Russ.

[Mr Mystery]

No such thing as a cheap shot. Loser is the loser, and that means Russ.

[Emerald Rose Widow]

No such thing as a cheap shot. Loser is the loser, and that means Russ.

I have to agree with Mystery on this one, cheap shot or no, if you win you win. When you are talking war and heresy, it doesn't matter who is right when it comes down to winners and losers.