I would have to say after reading feed back on the two books and get point to point break downs of both books I am a bit disappointed with both books. I understand the Inquisition is the in thing, but still rather irritated on the approach GET took with the two books. Before I begin I probably wind up buying the Inquisition codex, but will debate picking up sisters.
Anyway let me rant on the sisters. The only positive is that I can have a better chance somewhat on using faith it seems and priest are nice. Also the addition of lost gear, but overall it still is very weak when compared to other 6 codecs.
I mean the 2nd/ 3rd codex was a bit much I admit, but I was hoping for the White Dwarf nerf be fixed with this codex. Nope.
I can go on about how I hate this codex as bad as the last one. Overall I would say it's slightly better than the White Dwarf Dex and no where near as good as the 2nd edition codex. I can see the Jacobs and Celestine nerds, but at the same time it screws the army as a whole. On the plus side you can run a Cannoness now, although Jacobs is still a good option to take.
Depending on the Guard codex will answer if I bother with them or not. At the moment I rather have one point more sisters on an objective than plus four armoured veterans. The one and only troop choice for sisters can be argued that they are still one of the best cost effective troops out there, although guard have more weapon options via shooting.
Anyway they come across as an army made to either augment guard or use Inquisition to make them competitive. Honestly taking both guard and inquisition may be a good option to this army. If the priest abilities are transferable and the new guard codex do not have the same upgraded priest than that would be nice. Either way I have to wait for my guard codex to see if I will still even think about using this army.
Let's go to Inquisition the massive cut and paste codex. My disappointment here is that I can only run two HQs and three elites. Again making Cortez a mandatory character if you would like scoring warbands. I for one would like to run a strait Inquisition army which seems the only way to do it now is to run Grey Knights with Inquisition allies, which still probably have you using Grey Knight units to make up for lack of heavy support unless you count the monkey which I find insulting to use.
Anyway for at least any human faction army the Inquisition as allies is a no brainer. Again due to the block of annoying tactics it brings finding games with armies including with them will be hard to do.
Which brings up the question should I use them? I have the models, but due to Tau, Daemons, Bike Marines this add on will ban me a bandwagon player. However when they see metal sniper, shield, and old stealth suits they realized that the only new models in my Tau army happens to be Riptides or the fact I bought updated heralds for my Daemons or didn't buy anything for my bike marine army. Which I am not going to buy anything for Inquisition as well.
However I would like to bring my sister guard army back to the table. Ironically the Inquisition codex allows me to go back to my 3rd/ 4th edition sister army before all the updates. However due to the constant shifting nature of that army I am not sure I want to resurrect it.
First it was sisters with guard allies.
2nd Guard codex comes out and I have to 're work list
3rd sisters get 're amped and I lose guard allies and some sister units.
4th 6th bring back somewhat what I was running.
5th sisters changed again
6th Inquisition allows me to run the list I ran the first go round
7th new guard Dex over the horizon.
All that means I can choose to do sisters, marines, and inquisition which would be cool. In fact the Inquisition brings guard to the table so to speak, and I can use grey knight models for marines which would look nice, like Draigo would make a nice chapter master.
I just not too sure what to do. I always wanted to do an Imperial army with all the Imperial elements in it.