No ones saying after market companies like scibor puppet wars etc are bad and there really are loads of them, we are saying if you use copyright material then stick your fingers in your ears saying lalala, I can't hear you when people tell you your infringing copyright then you deserve to be sued. Remember the old adage don't buy the hand that feeds.
I wonder how much CHS lawyers pushed for appeal, I mean pro bono looks good for the company when you win, but here it wasn't really a win, they have to pay up so none of the pro bono teams can charge GW and reliably get paid, so they have nothing to lose from appealing.