Hehe Alright I apologize, I was hungry and if you could not tell I was bugging out b/c it makes me giggle. Lol Anyway here we go . . .
I gave my advice Biscuit. I said he should get the Avengers in Serpents, change the War Walker load outs, and reduce his number of Dragons. And then someone disagreed about Mech so I strongly disagreed. And when the OP started theory hammering I did it right back just to show a couple flaws in the logic.
@ Heimagiblin . . .
I know how Lances work and I did the math right.
And like I mentioned I did everything without guide and then said you can choose what to put guide on--I
cannot guess your thoughts. W/o guide that still leaves it at 3 turn death I believe, every two you will
immobilize/destroy.
And yes I know how to get 3+ cover for a tank.
Alright no more theory hammer, I did not want to from the start. I am sorry, I misread those parts of the post and the recap was after turn 1.
@ Tynskel, I am not dounting your abilities as a player or the fact that mech can win. I just believe that the best thing for his army is to mechanize it. It is a much more competitive choice, and easier to win with imo. Feel free to disagree but please give me reasoning. Also I have 3 troop choices at 2000 so I am not sure where you are going with that--my Eldar list would be the same. I think you need it at 2000.
And also I realized was making assumptions, but it was the choice I was given when he started theory hammering. I know you cannot predict everything and I understand everything you just said, but I respectfully disagree. I think most armies are better off with Mech; and I believe that only very few can pull off wins in competitive environments without mech (unless its foot-to-foot).