Having read the "Stop your whinging!" thread, I got to thinking of a brief thought experiment:
Premises:
40K is not perfectly balanced (the degree or even necessity of balance can be debated but the fact is undeniable)
There are rules that can be abused to make lists that are "unfun" to fight (be it unfluffy or OP or just plain annoying)
There are players that will abuse them. (whether this is a problem in your local meta is another issue)
Question:
What single adjustment (House rule) would you make to reduce abuse, while minimizing effects on general armies? Provide reasoning.
My initial concept would be: Characters cannot join allied units.
Reasoning:
Many of the "unfun" combos involve allied characters joining units specifically to buff them with special rules/psychic powers (aka Deathstars).
This becomes a significant area for abuse since while most character/unit combos within a codex have been/could have been thought through, cross codex combos are far harder to account for, making balance harder to achieve. By preventing this, many Deathstars would be eliminated which should increase the variety of armies. (As a side note, this likely would also lead to fewer Eldar (JB) Farseer/5 DA/Waveserpent ally lists which in turn would likely lead to a small reduction in the complaints about Eldar OPness)
This would not prevent players from fielding the same allies they already do, so would not require new models or remove old ones, and would not require any list changes, unless they player specifically builds to make deathstars )(in which case, by removing the deathstar crutch it should encourage greater personal development ) . It would also reduce anomalous rule interactions between codices creating unanticipated results or ambiguities.
On a fluff side it simplifies reasoning for allies (it's easier to explain fighting alongside another force than it is to explain why their boss has abandoned them to run with the allies), makes sense tactically (the allied leader leads his own troops) and can even justify backstory ("yes, they're allied, but Brother Captain Acute of the Space Angles hates Major Problem of the IG 177263rd Penal Battallion on a personal level, ever since...")