My friend and I played 1000pts cruiser clash but allowed escourt squadrons etc.
We are still learning the rules so we did away with terrain to avoid complication.
I had 1 Battle Barge, 6 Nova's and 5 Hunters
My friend had Gorbags revenge, 1 kill cruiser, 1 terror ship and some gunships and ram ships.
It was a big Melee but even so tactics and decision making really came into it. I really enjoyed the crippled rules, critical damage, catastrophic damage, gunnery chart, lance rules, movement and blast markers and more, not to mention the race specific rules or the amazing order rules. We had escorts bording each other, Drifting hulks hiding squadrons of Nova's from retaliation, ships on fire for several turns, massive broad sides at close range, Escort dogfights and Gorbags revenge eating marine escort squadrons one after the other.
The long and the short of it was that the Marines came out on top but both of us really enjoyed the game and could easily imagine in our minds eye what the rules were trying to convay. All the above and we barely even began to make full use of what the rules can allow you to do with all the other various senarios and terrain etc.
I think Gothic is brilliant.