No. Cos the codex represents the difference between VotLW and recent traitors. maybe they should have the Ld buff to begin with, and VotLW do something else
Maybe. very few people get Eternal Warrior, it should stay that way-Lucius, Typhus, Kharn and Ahriman should have eternal warrior. Pretty over guardsmen with meltas popping a 260pt special charactor.
Eldar, the Masters of all phsyic powers have no defence. Suck it up.Ahriman should count as having a familiar, a Master 4 10,000 yr old psyker with the knowledge of Magnus isn't going to blow himself up, Eldrad is the baseline for lvl4 psykers
You can argue that someone from a recent traitor legion should have access. But for simplicity...there'd be too many (some Land Raider vareints from the Heresy would be nice - If Techpriests can modify new varients surely the dark Mech can)All loyalist vehicles should be present in the CSM list, minus their machine spirits
Nope, I like them. You might not like the models. but they represent something that isn't done - warp vehicles-Dino-bots go to Codex Daemons.
This is good though.-Warlord Traits are useless, and the challenge rule should only count against other space marines
You contradict yourself a lot. You say you don't want a book that is just Loyal marines. And yet want the same stat line, you want all the same vehicles...want rid of the unique vehicles, want equivilent wargear....