I would like to see the armour be more like that of the current Mephiston model.
Duke
Yeah, they are, but the BAs are also supposed to be the artisans. The Ultramarines, to me, seem to be Roman only in the sense that they have crests on many of their helms and in a lot of their naming. Perhaps also in their rigid miliatry structure.
I think Romanesque was the right word choice, but you're certainlly right that the BAs are supposed to fall more along the lines of Italian renaissance (though Rome is in Italy!)
They are indeed renaisance, but by defenition that means they have very strong artistic elements that are based upon idolised Greek and Roman imagery as that was what the renaisance was about, the enlightment /re-enlightenment of european society, which for the most part meant attempting to recreate greek and roman society.
Tycho/Dante/Mephiston don't bother me, even with the flayed flesh look on mephiston, I'd just hate for the whole army to become absmarines. We already have too many 300-inspired chapters.
It's neoclassical/classical, just like ultramarines. Smurfs have a less specific style to it, the early styles are imho better described by these captains:
UM captain: [url]http://www.collecting-citadel-miniatures.com/wiki/index.php/Image:UM_Captain.jpg[/url]
Clearly a centurion.
BA captain: [url]http://www.collecting-citadel-miniatures.com/wiki/index.php/Image:BA_Captain.jpg[/url]
Mask recalling the mask of agamennon with a christian/medieval halo, anatomically correct like classical statues.
So maybe BA are more greek with a hint of baroque(over-decorated) and UM are more bland-roman.