Wewere having this discussion in our local club as the topic has become a hot one during an ongoing league. I posted this elsewhere, but figured I can get even more feedback here. My original post is followed by an answer and my response to that answer...
Guard platoon deploy as 1, whether normally or in reserve. This brings up some questions
--Do you HAVE to deploy the entire platoon or can a unit or two stay in reserve? According to the codex, they deploy as one.
--In turn, does this mean the oft used SWS in a vendetta flank marching is illegal?
--Also, doesn't this mean a platoon cannot be deployed during Dawn of War? You can only deploy 2 units from troops. You can have minimum 3 units in a troops choice.
And before anyone argues that point (not that I think anyone will), a platoon is not a unit. If so it must remain in unit coherency as a whole and the order affects the entire unit. We all know this doesn't happen.
However, my above questions raise some good points. Basically, according to the codex and the Dawn of War rules, a platoon cannot be deployed in a DoW mission. It must move on as a whole. The platoon is rolled for as a WHOLE when doing reserves or deployed as a WHOLE. It would also seem to affect some strategies many players have by using flank marching valks and vendettas to flank march parts of a platoon.
============================
you can decide to put individual units in reserve from a platoon....
in dawn of war, the platoon cannot be deployed as a whole..but some elements can be deployed as long as the limit of 2 troops (and note, the chimera is a SEPARATE unit for the purpose of DOW) is not broken...
============================
While the Dawn of War rules started the conversation, the rules on deployment continued it. It, to me at least, seems fairly explicit, yet confusing in it's description. If that makes any sense
"Each infantry platoon counts as a single Troops choice on the force organization chart when deploying, and is rolled collectively when rolling for reserves."
While I can see the potential for holding units in reserve, you can't hold them in a valkryie. There is nothing saying that Valk is coming on at the same time. It's not a dedicated transport, so is rolled seperately. As well, the entire platoon remnants would come on as a whole, at the same time. If you hold both SWS and a regular 10 man squad off in reserve, they come in together. The Valk rolls seperately. I don't see how this can really be worked around.